 Rapture
Futile
Spikefarm, 2000
Rapture is a band from
Finland, featuring members from Thy Serpent and Shape Of Despair. Their
debut effort, Futile, offers melancholic metal presented in rock-based
structural formats, with simplistic rhythms, weeping guitar melodies, and
semi-death metal vocals, occasionally offset by sleepy, disconsolate clean
singing. This musical concept will be a familiar one to those acquainted
with Katatonia’s 1996 album, Brave Murder Day, a work that the members of
Rapture were clearly inspired by during the creative process for their
first release. Indeed, it seems quite impossible for anyone who has heard
Brave Murder Day even once to not be reminded of it numerous times
throughout the listening experience of Futile. Nevertheless, despite its
complete lack of originality, the quality of this music shines through in
emotional expression and atmospheric brilliance. Rapture have taken Katatonia’s formula and nailed it to such an extent that it often rivals
their Swedish idols in execution and delivery.
"Early
morning rain
An eternal
sleepless 4 a.m.
Waking up to
silence
Into a slow
grey whatever" Operating from a minimalist
position towards song-structure, Rapture exercise sensations with the
"less is more" approach established to elegant result in the early works
of Katatonia. The drum work is similarly straightforward, acting as
nothing more than foundational currents shifting from up-tempo rock-based
simple drumming, to slower beats often peppered with tasteful yet subtle
embellishments, though the sound of the kit loses a bit of power in the
otherwise thick and clear production. Over this firm rhythmical base,
repetitious riffs in cyclical motion drive each composition, while
melancholic guitar melodies glide above. These sorrowful melodies,
inspired heavily by early Katatonia and Paradise Lost, are implemented
brilliantly, appealing to the emotional core of the listener and providing
this music with a richness of beauty that is a rare encounter. Witness the
descending/ascending melodies during the chorus of "To Forget", as well as
the title track, "This Is Where I Am" and the midnight metal-rock closer
"(About) Leaving" for evidence of the splendid employment of these
elegantly mournful guitar melodies. Rapture are highly skilled in the art
of emotional dynamic. There are moments when this music sweeps over the
listener in waves of beautiful melancholia, as in the build-ups succeeding
the acoustic guitar sections during "Futile" and "(About) Leaving)", and
the excellent emotional atmospheres of "Someone I (Don’t) Know", which
shifts from somber contemplation to despair-ridden anger in a fashion
recalling Katatonia’s "Rainroom". The vocals are serviceable, while
lacking a bit of character. At times the harsh vocals come off sounding
slightly forced. When not sounding forced, these vocals manage to get the
point across, but not in the convincing and distinct manner of a Jonas
Renske or Mikael Akerfeldt. It is the astounding implementation and
execution of mournful guitar melodies that serve as the band’s strength
and ultimately supply this music with its emotional wealth. The music,
even when charged, portrays grey-blue atmospheres of rainy day isolation
where the outside world becomes meaningless and hopeless, and all that
remains is a bitter sadness for the futility of it all.
"Tearing me
from my waking hours
Is the sweet
misery
Of a dark
day" In the end, the appeal of
this album will largely depend on how much value the listener places on
innovation/originality in art. If the listener places a high value on
innovation/originality in art despite its quality of performance, Futile
will come across as nothing but a complete ripoff of another band’s
formula (in this case, Katatonia). However, if the listener values quality
of presentation and communication of emotional relevance over uniqueness
of ideas, and additionally hungers for something (very) similar to Brave
Murder Day, Futile will provide many rewards. Few bands have tried their
talents at Katatonia’s melancholic metal minimalism despite its seemingly
simplistic formula, mostly because this particular concept allows little
opportunity for expansion before it is transformed into something other
than what it was, and also because regardless of how competent the
mechanics are, it is essentially the emotional realism of this music that
transcends all technicalities, and this cannot be replicated, only truly
felt. Rapture have employed these ideas while not attempting to expand on
them, instead offering their own interpretation of the previously
established concept, and have succeeded were others (Blazing Eternity,
Forest Stream, Daylight Dies) have fallen short.
9/21/06
Tracklisting:
1. Intro
2. To Forget
3. This Is Where I Am
4. The Fall
5. While The World Sleeps
6. Futile
7. Someone I (Don’t) Know
8. (About) Leaving
 Rapture
Songs For The Withering
Spikefarm, 2002 In the attempt to expand
their sound parameters beyond the Brave Murder Day fixation of
Futile, Rapture’s second release, Songs For The Withering,
finds the band slightly varying song-structures while relying less on the
sweeping melancholic guitar melodies that served as the strength of the
debut. A second vocalist has been welcomed in to deliver "clean" singing,
of which there is significantly more of than on the band’s first effort.
The result of these mild variations is a sound that not only still reminds
heavily of mid-era Katatonia, but now of latter-day Katatonia, as well as
late-90s Anathema, mostly during the more contemplative moments.
Vocally, the band have come
up with some sweetly somber harmonies by using the clean singing of Petri
as harmonic interplay with and offset to Henri's growls, most notably
during hooks and choruses of "Transfixion" and "Raintracks". "Two Dead
Names" and "The Vast" forsake the growls in favor of Petri's dispiriting
singing intermingling with sad melodies of clean guitars drifting into
walls of weeping riffs. These tracks, along with sections within
"Enveloped" and closing instrumental "Farewell" present an introspection
of sound that only briefly appeared on Futile ("Someone I (Don’t)
Know" and "While The World Sleeps"). The growls of Henri are again hit and
miss when it comes to delivering a desired emotional point convincingly.
This is most evident during the verses of "Nameless", where Henri growls
over a throbbing rhythm free of guitars. This sounds clumsy and entirely
un-atmospheric which works against what this band’s music aims for.
Elsewhere, these vocals are effective mostly when mingling with the clean
singing, or when executed over driving dark metal tracks like "Gallows".
Even when these vocals, both clean and growled, are at their best, they
are devoid of any real character, and are rendered only serviceable while
occasionally blending to establish beauty.
"Before
the last breath - inhale
before
the final death - exhale" Structurally, the songs are
again reliant on simplistic rhythms and traditional rock-song format,
though this is somewhat expanded here, mostly through diversity of
textures and the broader realm of ambience the band are allowed with a
second vocalist. The sound is massive, with all instruments granted a
clear and powerful place in the sound. At times the guitars create walls
of static sound while sorrowful leads of melodic splendor glide above.
This is brilliantly employed during "Enveloped", "Raintracks", and
"Transfixion", in which glorious guitar melodies fall like coldest rain on
evenings of late-Autumn tranquility. These transcendent moments present
Rapture at their strength, yet this album offers fewer such moments than
the debut.
Songs For The Withering
is an inconsistent work. "Transfixion", "Raintracks", "Gallows", Two
Dead Names" and "Enveloped" each offer instantly endearing melodies and
dark, emotional atmospheres on par with their first album. However, the
remainder of the album ranges from mediocre to weak, with much of this
portion clearly suffering from self-consciousness as the band attempt to
escape from the Katatonia-clone identity created by Futile. "The
Vast" and "The Great Distance" are injured by weak vocal phrases/delivery
and un-engaging melodies, "Nameless" is mostly awkward save for the
almost-there choruses, and the instrumental "Farewell" fails to close out
the album in the grand style it hoped to achieve, offering a promising
melodic/emotional idea at the start, before falling short of expanding
upon it in the crushing misery-towards-serenity thematic its early
whispers hinted at, instead retreating into its own hollowness. The
beautiful flow of melancholia that Futile delivered is disrupted
here by these poorly imagined and developed ideas. If Rapture sincerely
wants to make albums of atmospheric consistency and emotional captivation,
they need to forget about how their sound is perceived by critics and
remain sensitive to their inner voice.
9/24/06
Tracklisting:
1. Nameless
2. Gallows
3. Two Dead Names
4. Transfixion
5. The Vast
6. Raintracks
7. Enveloped
8. The Great Distance
9. Farewell
 Rapture
Silent Stage
Spikefarm, 2005 Rapture’s third album,
Silent Stage, largely follows the approach presented on previous
effort, Songs For The Withering, while faintly revealing an
identity of sound that could define their character as a band. Influences
of Katatonia and Anathema remain prominent throughout the material, yet
there is an inner voice that whispers elements of individuality during
certain passages. Song-structures remain centered on and driven by melodic
hooks and streamlined yet powerful rhythms, while acoustic guitars and
keyboards provide atmospherical dynamics. Vocals are again split between
deep growls and dejected, melodic singing. The production is again
massive, crystal clear, and powerful.
Where Songs For The
Withering offered a handful of excellent songs along with a few weaker
tracks, Silent Stage has less of both. The only song that can equal
the best of Songs For The Withering ("Transfixion", "Raintracks")
is "The Past Nightmares". This song is clearly the most powerful,
engaging, emotionally dynamic, and expertly arranged track on the album.
Storming rhythms, acoustic guitars, clever use of guitar effects for
ambience, emotional vocals, and effective display of dynamic emotions make
"The Past Nightmares" one of this band’s finest compositions. While there
is no other song on Silent Stage that matches this particular track
in the above-mentioned qualities, "Silent Chrysalis Stage" and "I Am
Complete" come close. "I Am Complete" succeeds where Songs For The
Withering’s "The Vast" failed. Both tracks feature the dispirited and
sometimes desperate clean singing of Petri Eskelinen over
near-radio-friendly melodic and dark rock music, yet "I Am Complete"
boasts a much more convincing application of melody and a stronger
performance by Eskelinen, who adapts his tone to the song’s shifting
dynamics very well here. The piano introducing an emotional build-up
towards the song’s closure is fantastic, and one of the best moments on
the disc.
"For once
this feels so real"
Mention must be made of the
two instrumentals on Silent Stage, "For The Ghosts Of Our Time" and
"Completion", which unlike Songs For The Withering’s "Farewell",
(which promised much at the start but ultimately failed to deliver)
display Rapture’s excellence in the realm of establishing emotional drama
through spacious ambience and melodic guitars. Without having to support
vocal phrases, these instrumentals are more expansive than the average
Rapture song, and are allowed more room to formulate and sustain
atmosphere. Rapture’s vocalists are essentially functionary in the scope
of what the music is aiming to achieve, and though these vocals are not
poor in delivery or quality in themselves, they lack strong character and
consistency in their respective approaches. Sometimes this is down to weak
phrasing, and other times it’s the indifference with which the lyrics are
expressed. These instrumentals represent Rapture at their atmospheric
best, showing a potential towards a higher level of captivation with
regards to pure feeling.
"The
darkness of mine
The
shattered and the painful light
Looming
close
Keeping
distance away from reach
It is
happening again..." Silent Stage
is free of any blatantly weak songs such as "The Vast" or "The Great
Distance" from Songs For The Withering. This makes the disc an
easier listen in its entirety. However, mechanical moments within a number
of songs mar the overall effectiveness of the album. "Misery 24/7", "The
Times We Bled" and "Dreaming Of Oblivion" each have uninteresting melodies
and vocal hooks during particular passages that spoil the potential of the
song’s main idea. If Rapture plays to their strengths (sweeping melodic
guitars, emotional dynamics) instead of incorporating functional segments
that make for uninspiring transitions, their sound would suffer less from
inconsistency in quality, both within certain tracks and from song to
song. The band possess a remarkable skill in exercising their pop
sensibilities within dark, melodic metal/rock, similar to latter-day
Sentenced and Cemetary, but they either don’t have enough strong ideas to
flesh out an entire album or they need to assert firmer discrimination
towards choosing what ideas work well. I like Rapture, and I’ll gladly
take them over any other current band who attempt to express melancholy
through melodic dark metal of the Katatonia tradition, because they have a
better understanding of how to generate the appropriate atmospheres and
expression of emotional struggle than bands such as the currently
much-hyped Daylight Dies (who over-complicate their material to the degree
that any amount of ambience they manage to establish through an idea is
quickly eradicated), but neither of the two works that have followed their
outstanding debut have managed to consistently capture the beautiful flow
of that first work.
9/28/06
Tracklisting:
1. Misery 24/7
2. The Past Nightmares
3. I Am Complete
4. For The Ghosts Of Our
Time
5. Silent Chrysalis Stage
6. Dreaming Of Oblivion
7. For The Times We Bled
(Closure)
8. Cold On My Side
9. Completion
Rapture
Spinefarm/Spikefarm
Rapture Discography
Futile (Spikefarm,
2000) Songs For
The Withering (Spikefarm, 2002)
Silent Stage (Spikefarm,
2005) |